Shakedown in New York (2018) [Grateful Dead]

A while back, I was listening to the Skull & Roses season of the Good Old Grateful Deadcast, and (I think) Gary Lambert mentioned at one point that a number of songs on that album date back to the shows at the Hammerstein Ballroom in April 1971. I can no longer recall his exact words, but I do remember that it was apparently a run that went completely over capacity. Coincidentally, I was listening to one of those shows at that moment, and it turned out to be the last show in a run of three. As far as I know, there is no official release, but you can find this under the title Shakedown in New York.

By the way, be careful with the release of Shakedown in New York, because according to the CD, it is a registration of the show of April 4, 1971. That is not the case, however, as this is the show from 2 days later. There are always plenty of reasons to give a listen to a Grateful Dead show you haven't heard before, but the closing act of the Dance Marathon performances stood out to me mainly because of the duo Oh Boy and I'm A Hog For You Baby. Two songs I haven't heard before (unless my memory - and my database - is seriously failing me right now), and I have somewhat mixed feelings about them. Oh Boy (a cover of The Crickets, best known for the presence of Buddy Holly) is a very nice cover, but I’m a Hog For You Baby… I don't know the original anyway, but that is definitely a song that isn't really my cup of tea. Although the three Dance Marathon shows were announced as “lasting as long as the audience kept dancing,” this one is actually a fairly short show by Grateful Dead standards. Apparently, this has to do with the fact that so many more tickets were sold than there was space available that there simply wasn't any room to dance. The show ultimately clocks in at around 2 hours and 20 minutes, and fortunately, we are treated to more than 20 songs within that time. There are also many transitions, with Greatest Story Ever Told > Johnny B. Goode, the classic Goin' Down The Road Feeling Bad > Not Fade Away, and the always great China Cat Sunflower > I Know You Rider.

Otherwise, there are plenty of songs you would expect in an early 70s Grateful Dead show. Loser always warms my heart, I have a soft spot for Beat It On Down The Line (it's just a shame that it takes a very long time for them to transition from Bertha to Beat It On Down The Line. Intuitively, the drumbeat that starts the song also feels a bit longer than normal to me, but that might just be me), and fans of American Beauty and Workingman’s Dead definitely get their money's worth here. I just can't quite put my finger on it, but it doesn't grab me by the scruff of the neck like other shows sometimes can. The 70s are full of fantastic shows (Red Rocks 7/8/78!), but I still prefer the late 70s just a little more than the early ones. No Dead show is ever the same, but during this period, there is a bit more familiarity. Although I must admit that I can always enjoy Pigpen, who once again delivers an excellent version of It Hurts Me Too here. Ultimately, only Playing in the Band would end up on Skull & Roses, but that version isn't really special. Although I've never really understood the appeal of that album anyway, but that is something for another time.

The third show at the Grand Ballroom/Manhattan Center - I feel like both names are frequently used interchangeably - and it was also the last time our friends played there. A number of these songs have been officially released over the years (Skull & Roses logically, but Oh Boy is also on the Complete Live Rarities Collection), but the concert itself hasn't received a official release. Apparently it was the only one of the three shows that was professionally recorded, but I would still like to check out the other two shows as well.

Tracklist:
  1. Bertha
  2. Beat It On Down The Line
  3. It Hurts Me Too
  4. Me And Bobby McGee
  5. Dire Wolf
  6. Oh Boy
  7. I'm A Hog For You Baby
  8. In The Midnight Hour
  9. Mama Tried
  10. Cumberland Blues
  11. Casey Jones
  12. Greatest Story Ever Told > Johnny B. Goode
  13. Loser
  14. Good Lovin'
  15. Sugar Magnolia
  16. Goin' Down The Road Feeling Bad > Not Fade Away
  17. Truckin'
  18. Big Boss Man
  19. China Cat Sunflower > I Know You Rider


Comments