1978/11/24 Capitol Theatre, Passaic, NJ, USA [Grateful Dead]

November 24 1978 is yet another Capitol Theatre show. Is it that I have a special preference for this venue? Not really, but 1978 is one of my favorite years in terms of the group's performances, and since Shakedown Stream has called it quits, I have to search for full shows on YouTube. As luck would have it, this November show can be found in good quality. The naming of set 1 and set 2 has been swapped, so you have to start with Jack Straw and not I Need a Miracle, but that actually matters little, because both sets are truly on fire.

And that is strange in itself, because Garcia is actually not in good voice at all here. The show a day later at the Veterans Coliseum in Arizona was subsequently canceled (funny detail: there is even an audience recording of that where you hear Bob Weir saying that they have to cancel the show because Garcia is sick and has pneumonia, but that they will come back. Something that would effectively happen in January 1979), but what he lacks in voice, he makes up for with his guitar playing. Just take a look at this version of Shakedown Street and enjoy the delightful solo he conjures up at the end. Sugaree also crackles with energy from all sides. Apparently, this show was intended as a promotional show for the Shakedown Street album, which had been released just a few days earlier, and you can certainly feel that in the setlist with no fewer than 5 songs. A number of regulars like Stagger Lee and Fire on the Mountain, but also a beautiful version of From the Heart of Me by Donna Godchaux.

I have no idea if it was due to Garcia sensing that his voice wasn't on par, but in this show you are actually served a double dose of Donna, including the amazing Passenger. A song they played far too little during the Godchaux era for my liking (and to my surprise, I see they even played it a few times in the early 80s; I wonder who handled the vocals there), but that harmony with Bob Weir remains simply wonderful. In any case, I always find it really cool to see those two performing together. Donna’s husband Keith Godchaux is also in great form here, by the way; what a difference compared to the show in Egypt or the closing of Winterland. And speaking of Egypt, how nice that none other than Hamza El Din suddenly appears during Drums. This is perhaps one of my favorite Drums across all their concerts. For me, it is always the weakest part of a concert, but here the boys engage in a sort of drum duel, and although Ollin Arageed isn't entirely my cup of tea, it does provide a certain rhythm and vibe that I can appreciate.

It's a shame that Garcia isn't quite in top vocal form (Loser and Fire on the Mountain certainly suffer from that), because otherwise this could have ended up very high. An ultra-slow Friend of the Devil, which even gets almost a completely different arrangement if I am to believe my non-musical ears, sounds amazing, and this is perhaps the best version of Shakedown Street I have ever heard. Add to that Passenger and an excellent I Need a Miracle > Good Lovin (the first is far from my favorite song, the second one comes close) and you really have a delightful show.

Tracklist:
  1. Jack Straw
  2. Sugaree
  3. Me and My Uncle
  4. Big River
  5. Stagger Lee
  6. Passenger
  7. Candyman
  8. New Minglewood Blues
  9. From the Heart of Me
  10. Loser
  11. Promised Land
  12. I Need a Miracle
  13. Good Lovin'
  14. Friend of the Devil
  15. Estimated Prophet
  16. Shakedown Street
  17. Ollin Arrageed
  18. Drums
  19. Fire on the Mountain
  20. Sugar Magnolia
  21. Johnny B. Goode




Comments