It doesn't happen often that I start a Grateful Dead post with something negative, but what an annoying tracklist. Not the concert itself, which is amazing, but just the fact that this is the complete recording of November 5, 1977, and that some tracks from a different date were added halfway through. I know that is often the case with these specific releases, but still… It Must Have Been the Roses transitions into Might as Well, and for a band where the flow of a concert is quite important, this is a mess. There are supposed to be a bunch of other tracks between Might as Well and Estimated Prophet, and actually, Around and Around is the last song of the November 2 concert. Because of this, you also get two standalone versions of Estimated Prophet (which feels very strange to me), and right at the end, you get Lazy Lightnin' > Supplication. It is a real shame that somehow they didn't just ensure that the full November 5 concert was released integrally (without songs that don't belong there) on the three discs. I understand that David Lemieux and co. want to give the fans their money's worth, but to be honest, this annoys me more than it makes me happy. Fortunately, the quality of the songs is beyond question. 1977 is a great year for the Grateful Dead, and Donna Godchaux in particular sounds amazing here. A very fine version of Looks Like Rain, and although I'm not such a huge fan of Candyman, that song still manages to charm me even here. Sound-wise, this also sounds fantastic, and it's nice to hear Phil Lesh play a solo for a change. It is accompanied by the classic Take a Step Back, and it just goes to show once again what a great job Betty Cantor-Jackson delivered. The mastering was done from her original two-track analog reel-to-reel tapes, and it sounds really good. It's just a real shame about that botched tracklist. I think I'm just going to make my own version of the Dick’s Picks on Spotify, though this time in the correct order.
Tracklist:
- New Minglewood Blues
- Mississippi Half-Step Uptown Toodeloo
- Looks Like Rain
- Dire Wolf
- Mama Tried
- Big River
- Candyman
- Jack Straw
- Deal
- Phil Solo
- Take a Step Back
- Eyes of the World
- Samson and Delilah
- It Must Have Been the Roses
- Might as Well
- Estimated Prophet
- St. Stephen
- Truckin'
- Around and Around
- Estimated Prophet
- He's Gone
- Rhythm Devils
- The Other One
- Black Peter
- Sugar Magnolia
- One More Saturday Night
- Lazy Lightning
- Supplication

Comments
Post a Comment